St. Michael’s-Pojoaque Playoff Fight Raises NMAA Eligibility Questions Ahead of Moriarty Semifinal

SANTA FE, N.M. — Multiple players from St. Michael’s High School and Pojoaque Valley High School left their respective sideline areas and entered the playing field during a fourth-quarter altercation in Saturday’s Class 3A state football quarterfinal, raising eligibility questions ahead of St. Michael’s upcoming semifinal matchup against Moriarty despite no additional ejections appearing to be assessed on the field.

The incident occurred with 8:42 remaining in the Nov. 14 contest in Santa Fe, which top-seeded St. Michael’s won 49-0 over No. 8 Pojoaque Valley. During the altercation, a Pojoaque Valley player was on top of a St. Michael’s player and threw multiple punches, while players from both sidelines came onto the field. It did not appear that any other players physically engaged in the altercation, nor did it appear that players other than the two involved in the fight were ejected during the game.

As players from both sidelines entered the field, the camera recording the game was suddenly tilted upward toward the sky, avoiding capturing the remainder of what was happening on the playing surface.

The apparent lack of additional on-field ejections contrasts with New Mexico Activities Association (NMAA) regulations and National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS) playing rules, which state that leaving the bench or team box area during an altercation is an automatic violation, regardless of whether an athlete throws a punch or attempts to break up a fight.

NMAA Rules on Leaving the Bench

Under NMAA Section VII (Sports Regulations) and Bylaw 7.7.2 (Game/Contest Ejection Policy), any player, coach or member of bench personnel who leaves the coaching or bench area to enter the playing surface during an altercation is automatically deemed guilty of fighting. Under NFHS playing rules, only head coaches are permitted to enter the field during an altercation, and solely to restore order and keep their players on the sideline.

Any player disqualified or ejected for leaving the bench faces mandatory minimum sanctions under NMAA Bylaw 7.7.2:

  • First Ejection: An automatic minimum one-game suspension at the same level of competition. The athlete is prohibited from participating at any level—including junior varsity or varsity—until the suspension is served, and must complete the NFHSLearn “Sportsmanship” online course and submit a completion certificate to the school’s athletic director before returning to play.
  • Battery Escalation: If an altercation escalates to battery—defined as the use of force against another resulting in harmful or offensive contact—the suspension increases to 15% of the sport’s regular-season game limitation, rounded up. In varsity football, which has a 10-game regular-season limit, 15% rounds up to a two-game suspension.
  • Subsequent Ejections: A second ejection in the same school year results in a two-game suspension and a mandatory meeting with the NMAA executive director or designee. A third ejection results in removal from all athletic competition for 180 school days or 365 calendar days.

Suspended athletes are prohibited from dressing out in uniform, participating in warm-ups or being directly involved in a contest. They may sit on the bench or sideline in street clothes only if approved by local school administration.

Post-Game Review and Institutional Penalties

Under NMAA guidelines, officials must submit incident reports following ejections, and the association retains the authority to review game video and issue retroactive suspensions if unflagged violations are identified.

If multiple players leave the bench and are ejected in the same contest, or if a school accumulates multiple ejections during a school year, the school faces additional sanctions under NMAA Bylaw 7.7.4. Those penalties can include mandatory NFHS courses for the athletic director, fines ranging from $100 to $250 or more, meetings with the NMAA executive director and potential placement under the association’s Two-Strikes Rule, which carries the risk of probation or forfeiture of postseason eligibility.

Ejections are treated as non-appealable judgment calls by game officials unless clear video evidence demonstrates misidentification of a player, in which case footage must be submitted to the NMAA executive director for review.

St. Michael’s (10-0) is scheduled to host No. 4 seed Moriarty (9-2) in the Class 3A state semifinals. Pojoaque Valley concluded its season with a 6-6 record.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *